A Rich, But Disappearing Legacy: Remembering Black Boarding Schools - A Tradition Obscured by Desegregation's Impact By Ronald Roach
Reprinted with permission from Diverse: Issues In Higher Education, www.diverseeducation.com
There's no
doubt that the commemoration of the 50th anniversary of the landmark
Brown v. Board school desegregation case next year will generate
much-needed discussion about the ongoing struggle over providing quality
education for American children, especially for those in the Black,
Latino and American Indian communities.
While a good
deal of the celebration will applaud the historic efforts of courageous
scholars and lawyers, such as Charles Hamilton Houston, Thurgood
Marshall and Dr. Kenneth Clark, to desegregate the public schools, there
likely won't be much, if any, attention paid to another distinct
tradition that sought the best education possible for Black children
during the segregation era. The tradition belongs to historically Black
boarding schools, of which there were more than 100 in the United States prior to the 1970s.
Currently, only four such schools are in operation.
"It was an excellent educational option, and it is the kind of option I wish we had available today," says North Carolina Central University provost Dr. Lucy Reuben, who attended a Black boarding school known as the Mather School in Beaufort, S.C., during her high school years.
Alumni of these
schools, which were primarily based in the South, decry the loss of
these institutions, which came about in large part from enrollment
declines and financial hardship after desegregation opened up all-White
public schools to Black students. These independent boarding schools had
made up a significant part of the educational infrastructure for Blacks
between the Civil War and the civil rights movement. When southern
states and localities failed to provide schools for Black children,
local Blacks, religious organizations and philanthropists took it upon
themselves to build independent elementary and secondary schools.
"The schools
that became boarding schools were often the only places in a particular
community where Blacks could be educated," says Dr. Charles Beady Jr.,
the president of the Piney Woods School in Mississippi.
Among the Black boarding schools, the Mather schools in Beaufort and Camden, S.C., Palmer Memorial Institute and Laurinburg Institute in North Carolina, Snow Hill Institute in Alabama, Gilbert Academy in New Orleans, Piney Woods in Mississippi and Boggs Academy in Georgia are some of the better known institutions.
To those who
attended the Black boarding schools, the tradition imbued them with a
profound sense of community, religious devotion for those at the
church-affiliated schools, and a commitment to academic excellence,
qualities they believe are rarely replicated in the lives of
contemporary Black students.
"I can say that Mather provided a truly rigorous and character-building experience," Reuben says.
Today, a number
of the boarding school alumni groups have reunions on an annual basis
and a few work on historic preservation projects relating to their alma
maters. The four existing Black boarding schools have recently begun
efforts to reach out to the alumni of the ones that have closed.
PIONEERING EFFORTS
Laurence C.
Jones, Charlotte Hawkins Brown and Rachel Crane Mather may not be
household names, but as founders of Black boarding schools they are held
in high esteem in Black education history for establishing schools
under difficult circumstances. While dozens of schools were founded
during the late 1800s and early 1900s, a number of them rose to
prominence based on the extraordinary perseverance and leadership of
individual founders. Others flourished under the largess of religious
organizations and philanthropic interests.
The founder of the Palmer Memorial Institute in Sedalia, N.C.,
Charlotte Hawkins Brown is said to have led her school to considerable
prominence as one of the top academies for Black students in the United States.
With few resources, Brown established Palmer in 1902. Prior to
launching Palmer, Brown had held an American Missionary Association
teaching job at the Bethany Congregational Church in Sedalia.
After the school closed within a year of Brown's arrival, the young
teacher stayed in the community and opened Palmer, which she would head
for 50 years.
The school was named in honor of Alice Freeman Palmer, Brown's mentor and benefactor. Palmer was the second woman president of Wellesley College in Wellesley, Mass.
Like many of
its counterparts, Palmer was founded as an agricultural and manual
training facility. Over time, it evolved into an accredited college
preparatory academy that drew Black students from around the nation and
from overseas. During Brown's tenure as president, more than 1,000
students graduated from the school. Palmer would eventually close in
1971.
Dr. Roselyn Payne Epps, professor emeritus of pediatrics and child health at the Howard University medical school, remembers Charlotte Hawkins Brown as a capable and determined leader.
"She was a very dynamic and strong woman," says Epps, who graduated from Palmer in 1947.
Epps went to
Palmer as a 12-year-old ninth-grader along with her older brother. As
the child of parents who were an administrator and faculty member at
what is now Savannah State University,
Epps recalls having the time of her life as a student. "It was a
wonderful experience. It was culturally enriching and a great
education," she says.
Delphine Patton
Sneed, an arts instructor at the University of Maryland-Baltimore
County, graduated from Palmer in 1968 in a class of 48 students and
recalls her time at the North Carolina
school as a transformative one. "It was absolutely the best thing my
parents did for me. It was really a life-altering experience;" Sneed
says.
She says she was a shy, awkward teenage girl who had grown up in the South Bronx before her mother sent her off to Palmer as a 10th-grader, paying annual tuition, room and board fees of $1,200.
"I went to
Palmer very shy, gangly and nerdy. By the time I graduated, I was Miss
Thing. I had developed into quite a socially aware young lady," Sneed
says.
Sneed says the
interaction with her classmates and teachers who were from all over the
nation and overseas stimulated her to excel academically and develop
self-confidence.
As a board
member of the Palmer Memorial Institute in its later years, Epps recalls
that the school had great difficulty with raising funds to sustain the
school's economic model. "It was a small school that had at most 200
students," she says, adding that fund-raising efforts could not keep
pace with rising costs associated with maintaining dormitories, dining
facilities and academic buildings.
Lacking the
national network that its founder Brown had relied on when she ran the
school and hit with a fire that destroyed the main academic building,
school leaders had to close the school in 1971, according to Epps.
By the 1980s,
Palmer alumni and former teachers had organized a foundation to
establish a museum on the site of the old school, according to Tracey
Burns-Vann, the director of the Charlotte Hawkins Brown Museum. The state of North Carolina designated the Palmer campus as an official state historic site, the first recognizing Black history in North Carolina.
"It's a wonderful resource for North Carolina," Burns-Vann says.
In Beaufort, S.C., alumni of the Mather school recently met in Hilton Head Island for a reunion of the formerly all-girls academy that became coeducational in the 1960s.
Reuben of North Carolina Central says she attended the school just two years before returning home to Sumter, S.C.,
where she integrated a formerly all-White public high school. She
credits the Mather experience for helping her develop the
self-confidence she would need during the experience of integrating an
all-White school.
Reuben recalls
that the racially mixed Mather teaching staff had high expectations of
students and they encouraged student ambitions to attend college at the
nation's most competitive institutions.
The
school's founder, Rachel Crane Mather, established the school, which
would bear her name, in 1867 under the auspices of the American
Missionary Association. Over time, both a highly regarded accredited
high school and junior college would flourish at the Beaufort campus.
The junior college, established in 1954, was coed from the start while
the all-girls boarding high school went coed in the early 1960s. Both
the high school and junior college closed in 1968, and Mather junior
college students and archives were accepted by Benedict College in Columbia, S.C.
"We
were exposed to cultural activities and were expected to be
sophisticated and cultured women," says Vernell Young, a Mather alumna
from Virginia Beach, Va.
Currently, Benedict College also coordinates Mather's alumni reunions, and the Beaufort Lowcountry Technical College, which was established on the Mather campus by the state of South Carolina, invites the alumni to an annual ringing of a bell that belonged to the boarding school. At the recent reunion in Hilton Head Island,
Mather alumnus talked about working with the technical college to have a
room in one of the campus buildings designated in honor of the boarding
school, according to officials.
While Black
boarding schools generally evolved from agricultural and industrial
training schools into college preparatory academies, some schools
retained some of its technical and vocational character.
Cherryl Matthews, an elementary school principal in Baton Rouge, La., recalls that her high school, Boggs Academy in Keysville, Ga.,
a boarding school established by the Presbyterian church, offered three
tracks for its students. Most students like Matthews opted for the
college preparatory curriculum, but a number of students followed a
business curriculum, which prepared them for jobs after high school such
as in bookkeeping and office management. A third group, comprised of a
few students who were from the local community, learned technical trades
at Boggs.
Matthews, who was from Columbia, S.C.,
says her parents, who were schoolteachers, felt strongly that a private
Black boarding school would provide her a far better education and
enriching cultural experience than the segregated public schools in her
hometown.
THE POWER OF PINEY WOODS
Founded in 1909
by Laurence Jones, Piney Woods is by far the best known Black boarding
school largely because of its high-profile fund-raising efforts and the
back-to-basics philosophy employed at the school. Only Laurinburg
Institute in Laurinburg, N.C., founded in 1904, has been around longer than Piney Woods. The other two existing schools are Pine Forge Academy in Pennsylvania, which was founded in 1946, and Redemption Christian Academy in New York, founded in 1979. The four schools form the Association of Historically African American Boarding Schools.
Dr. Dolphus
Weary, a Piney Woods board member and alumnus, says he believes that
Piney Woods has managed to survive largely because of the original
vision of its founder, Laurence Jones.
"He was a guy who knew how to take the long view," Weary says.
Jones had long established support and relationships that were extensive in Mississippi and outside the state, according to Weary.
The Piney Woods campus is located just 21 miles southwest of Jackson, Miss.,
and sits on 2,000 acres of rolling hills, forest, open fields and
lakes. The school enrolls 300 students from ninth through 12th grade.
The self-sufficient campus has a post office, a farm, athletic fields,
chapel and amphitheater.
Students come from more than 20 states, Mexico, the Caribbean
and African nations. Its student body profile includes kids who are in
need of an opportunity to leave their home communities for a school
environment where they can reach their full potential, according to
school officials. Administrators say students often come from
single-parent households and from working-class and low-income
communities.
"We want the
student who knows that going to Piney Woods is a privileged opportunity
and a blessing," says Marvin Jones, an administrator at Piney Woods.
The school has a
$6 million annual operating budget, and full tuition, including room
and board is $13,000 annually. Because many students come from
low-income and working-class backgrounds and are subsidized by
scholarship support, students pay an average of $3,500 a year to attend,
according to Jones.
Students adhere
to strict discipline at Piney Woods. They are required to perform
chores, which include working on the school farm. Class attendance is
mandatory, and students have to study two hours nightly. At 5:30 a.m.
each weekday, students and faculty must attend prayer service, and they
must attend three church services on Sundays, according to school
officials.
Aware that
there are thousands of alumni of Black boarding schools scattered across
the country, school president Beady hit on an idea in 2002 to rally
them in support of Piney Woods, the largest of the four schools.
Working from a
partial list of Black boarding schools, Beady organized the 1st National
Black Boarding Schools Weekend Celebration, which was held in Los Angeles
this past April. An estimated 400 people attended the event, which
netted the school more than $1 million in pledges. Prior to the April
event, Beady reached out to the heads of the other three boarding
schools and won their support for the idea of a national Black boarding
school weekend. He says the association will be working together on
future national reunions and a radio-thon to raise funds for all four
schools.
Not unlike
Jones, Beady has cast a wide net in maintaining support for Piney Woods.
Celebrities, such as Oprah Winfrey and Morgan Freeman, have donated
money and have lent their names to campaigns for Piney Woods. The school
also benefits from having radio mogul Cathy Hughes on its board. Hughes
is a granddaughter of Jones, the founder.
Beady, who has
been the school president since 1985, says the school is pushing hard to
rebuild its endowment which took a beating during the stock market
meltdown over the past few years. He says the endowment is nearly $20
million. At the height of the stock market boom in the late 1990s, the
endowment was at $40 million, according to Beady.
Tapping the
legacy of the Black boarding school tradition and reaching out to the
alumni represents a strategy that could not only mean more dollars for
the current Black boarding schools, but might stimulate greater national
interest in the historic tradition of Black boarding schools, according
to Beady. Though they can not point to a comprehensive list of all the
Black boarding schools that existed, Piney Woods officials hope they
will be able to put one together.
"The alumni of
the boarding schools are precisely the people who would be most
sensitive to our mission," Beady says. "Instead of them meeting every
year to talk about the good old days, we want to give these alumni
something that is forward-looking to support."
Partial Listing of Closed Historically Black Boarding Schools
* Bettis Academy--South Carolina
* Boggs Academy--Georgia
* Dowington Industrial Institute--Pennsylvania
* Fargo Agricultural School--Arkansas
* Gilbert Academy--Louisiana
* Haines Normal and Industrial Institute--Georgia
* Mather Academy--Camden, S.C.
* Mather School--Beaufort, S.C.
* Okolona School--Mississippi
* Palmer Memorial Institute--North Carolina
* Prentiss Institute--Mississippi
* Schofield Industrial School--South Carolina
* Snow Hill Institute--Alabama
Source: Piney Woods School
Out of the
approximately 100 Black boarding schools that originally existed only
the following four remain, forming the Association of Historically
African American Boarding Schools:
* Laurinburg Institute, North Carolina
* Pine Forge Academy, Pennsylvania
* Piney Woods, Mississippi
* Redemption Christian Academy, New York
Black Issues in Higher Education , August 14, 2003
|